HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS		QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced] Author: Keyword(s): Year:  Vol:  Page:

This Article Abstract Figures Only Full Text (PDF) Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Similar articles in PubMed Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Sijbrandij, E. S. Articles by de Lange, E. E. Search for Related Content PubMed PubMed Citation Articles by Sijbrandij, E. S. Articles by de Lange, E. E. Social Bookmarking                      What's this?

Posttraumatic Subchondral Bone Contusions and Fractures of the Talotibial Joint

Occurrence of "Kissing" Lesions

¹ Department of Radiology, University Hospital Utrecht and Central Military Hospital, Heidelberglaan 100, 3509 AA Utrecht, The Netherlands.
² Department of Orthopedics, University Hospital Utrecht and Central Military Hospital, 3509 AA Utrecht, The Netherlands.
³ Department of Radiology, University of Virginia Health Sciences Center, 100 Lee St., Charlottesville, VA 22902.

Received March 31, 2000; accepted after revision May 31, 2000.

 
Address correspondence to E. S. Sijbrandij.

Abstract

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 
OBJECTIVE. The objective of this study was to determine the presence and location of subchondral bone contusions, fractures, and "kissing" lesions of the talotibial joint after a sprain of the ankle shown on MR imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS. We retrospectively reviewed the images of all consecutive patients who underwent MR imaging of the ankle after acute or recurrent sprain occurring between January and December 1997. The number and location of subchondral contusions or fractures revealed on MR imaging were recorded, and a comparison was made with the radiographs obtained for each patient.

RESULTS. Of the 146 ankles, 42 osteochondral lesions were revealed on MR imaging in 26 ankles (18%) involving 23 patients. Twenty-three lesions were localized in the dome of the talus and 19, in the tibiofibular plafond. In 16 (11%) of the 146 ankles, the lesions were present in the opposing bones of the joint ("kissing" lesions). Only six of the 12 talar fractures and none of the tibial fractures involving the 26 ankles were seen on conventional radiography.

CONCLUSION. Subchondral lesions in the talus and tibia are relatively common after ankle trauma, occurring in 18% of patients in our series. Kissing lesions were present in more than half of the lesions in these patients.

Introduction

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 
A ligamental sprain is one of the most common sports-related injuries of the ankle [1]. When the pain persists, the possibility of an osteochondral contusion or fracture of the dome of the talus should be considered [1]. Studies reveal that patients with a disability after an ankle sprain show an osteochondral fracture of the talus more often than expected [2, 3]. Repeated trauma can lead to a more severe osteochondral injury that, in turn, may result in progressive disability [4]. The osteochondral lesions, particularly when the injury is minor, are generally not revealed on conventional radiography [1, 2, 5].

The most widely accepted classification of osteochondral talar injury, introduced by Berndt and Harty [5] and based on research on cadavers, is as follows: stage 1 is localized area of subchondral trabecular compression; stage 2 is incomplete separation of the transchondral fragment; stage 3, the fragment is completely separated but not displaced; stage 4, the fragment is displaced or inverted in its fracture bed. The first two stages are difficult to show on conventional radiography, and the lesions may go undetected when radiographs are obtained for evaluation. MR imaging shows the lesions with high sensitivity, allowing early detection and treatment of the abnormal findings [1].

In patients with traumatic osteochondral contusions of the dome of the talus, similar lesions can be seen occasionally on the opposite site of joint, the tibiofibular plafond. Lundeen [6] in 1990, using arthroscopy, was one of the first to postulate that the tibial lesions were the result of the talus impinging on the cartilage of the tibial plafond at the time of injury. Similar findings, referred to as "kissing" contusions, have also been described in the knee [7]. Bone bruises are common after severe ankle sprain. To our knowledge, no detailed studies exist on bone bruises associated with osteochondral fractures in the ankle. Canosa [8] was the first to describe the CT appearance of the kissing lesions in the ankle in a patient who had an osteochondral fracture of the talus and a mirror image fracture of the adjacent tibial plafond.

We noted in our patients undergoing MR imaging of the ankle after injury a relative high incidence of subchondral bone contusions, fractures, and kissing lesions involving the talus and tibiofibular plafond. The purpose of our study was to determine the presence and location of subchondral bone contusions, fractures, and kissing lesions of the talotibial joint after a sprain of the ankle shown on MR imaging.

Materials and Methods

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 
We retrospectively reviewed 146 images of all consecutive patients who had undergone MR imaging of the ankle at our institution for sustained acute or recurrent injury to the ankle from January 1997 to December 1997. Abnormalities of the subchondral bones were found in 26 ankles, involving 23 patients. Twenty of these patients were males and three were females, with ages ranging from 12 to 51 years (mean age, 30 years). Seventeen of the 23 patients were military recruits. All patients could relate the symptoms to acute or recurrent sprains of the ankle. Time between injury and imaging varied from 1 to 43 weeks (mean time, 14 weeks). In all patients symptoms such as stiffness, swelling, and pain aggravated by weight-bearing or activity after an episode of trauma persisted [2, 3]. The indication for performing MR imaging was the clinical suspicion of osteochondral injury established by an experienced orthopedic foot surgeon.

MR imaging was performed on a 0.5-T unit (Philips Medical Systems, Best, The Netherlands) with the ankle placed in a dedicated receive-only extremity coil. Conventional T1-weighted spin-echo images (TR/TE, 600/23) and T2-weighted spin-echo images (2000/100) were obtained in sagittal and coronal orientations in all patients. Short tau inversion-recovery (STIR) images (3600/20; inversion time, 150 msec) were obtained in the coronal orientation. Image section thickness ranged from 3 to 5 mm with an interslice gap of 0.0-1.5 mm. Matrix size was 256 x 256, and the field of view was 16 cm. All patients also underwent radiography of the ankle in anteroposterior, lateral, and mortise projections.

The MR images were reviewed with special attention paid to bony abnormalities suggestive of osteochondral contusions or fractures. Associated ligamentous injuries were not evaluated in this study. Two radiologists reviewed the images in consensus, and the diagnosis of a contusion was based on the criteria described by Kaplan et al. [7] and Magee and Hinson [9]: the presence of a subchondral well-defined semicircular area of decreased signal intensity on T1-weighted images and increased signal intensity on T2-weighted and STIR images. An osteochondral fracture was considered present when disruption of the subchondral bone plate extending through the cortical surface was identified on T2-weighted images. After evaluation of each MR study, the reviewers analyzed the ankle radiographs of each patient. In addition, all MR images and radiographs of the ankle obtained during the 2 years after the initial injury were reviewed.

Results

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 
Of the 146 consecutive MR examinations of the ankle performed for persistent symptoms after sprain, 42 abnormalities of the subchondral bones were found in 26 ankles (18%), involving 23 patients. The 42 subchondral lesions were present in 17 right and nine left ankles, with 23 lesions in the talus and 19 in the tibia. In 13 of the 42 lesions, MR imaging findings were consistent with fractures, and in the remaining 29, findings were consistent with contusions. Twelve fractures were located in the talus and one, in the tibia. Seven of the 23 talar and three of the 19 tibial plafond lesions were present on only one side of the joint. We found no significant difference in time between the injury and imaging in patients with and in those without bone contusions or fractures. In 16 ankles, the subchondral lesions involved the two opposing bones of the talotibial joint (kissing contusions). In six of these ankles, the subchondral lesions were diametrically opposed and involved the weight-bearing area (Figs. 1A,1B,1C and 2A,2B,2C). In the remaining 10 ankles, the lesions were not directly opposed (Figs. 3A,3B,3C and 4A,4B,4C). All except one of the 16 kissing lesions involving the tibia were contusions. Only seven contusions were seen in the talus, whereas a majority (n = 9) of the talar lesions were osteochondral fractures. Only six of the 12 talar fractures and none of the tibial fractures involving the 26 ankles were revealed on conventional radiography.

View larger version (138K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 1A. —31-year-old man 2 weeks after ankle sprain. Anteroposterior radiograph of right ankle shows no abnormal findings.

View larger version (122K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 1B. —31-year-old man 2 weeks after ankle sprain. Coronal short tau inversion-recovery image (TR/TE, 3600/20; inversion time, 150 msec) shows bone contusions in opposing areas of medial tibia (arrowhead) and medial talar dome (arrow). Contusions are recognized by areas of increased signal intensity.

View larger version (140K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 1C. —31-year-old man 2 weeks after ankle sprain. Coronal T1-weighted spin-echo MR image (600/23) shows decreased signal intensity (arrow) in medial talar dome.

View larger version (128K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 2A. —22-year-old man 6 weeks after distortion of left ankle. Anteroposterior radiograph shows no abnormal findings.

View larger version (121K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 2B. —22-year-old man 6 weeks after distortion of left ankle. Coronal short tau inversion-recovery image (TR/TE, 3600/20; inversion time, 150 msec) shows bone contusion in opposing areas of medial tibial plafond (V) and osteochondral fracture in medial talar dome (arrow).

View larger version (170K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 2C. —22-year-old man 6 weeks after distortion of left ankle. Sagittal T1-weighted spin-echo MR image (600/23) shows osteochondral fracture in medial talar dome (arrow) and bone contusion in tibial plafond (arrowhead).

View larger version (144K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 3A. —42-year-old man with persistent pain after recurrent sprains of right ankle. Anteroposterior radiograph of ankle shows osteochondral defect in lateral aspect of talus (arrow).

View larger version (125K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 3B. —42-year-old man with persistent pain after recurrent sprains of right ankle. Coronal short tau inversion-recovery image (TR/TE, 3600/20; inversion time, 150 msec) shows osteochondral lesion in lateral talus (arrow) and osteochondral lesions in medial tibial plafond (V). Lesions are not diametrically opposed probably as result of rotation during injury.

View larger version (167K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 3C. —42-year-old man with persistent pain after recurrent sprains of right ankle. Coronal T1-weighted spin-echo MR image (600/23) shows osteochondral fracture in lateral talus (arrow) and osteochondral contusion in medial tibial plafond (arrowhead).

View larger version (135K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 4A. —25-year-old man 7 weeks after severe sprain of left ankle. Anteroposterior radiograph of left ankle shows no abnormal findings.

View larger version (154K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 4B. —25-year-old man 7 weeks after severe sprain of left ankle. Coronal short tau inversion-recovery image (TR/TE, 3600/20; inversion time, 150 msec) shows bone contusions in opposing areas of medial tibial plafond (V) and lateral talar dome (arrow). Contusions are recognized by areas of increased signal intensity.

View larger version (155K): [in this window] [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide]   Fig. 4C. —25-year-old man 7 weeks after severe sprain of left ankle. Coronal T1-weighted spin-echo MR image (600/23) shows osteochondral contusions in lateral talar dome (arrow) and tibial plafond (arrowhead). Contusions are not diametrically opposed probably as result of rotation.

Of the 23 patients, arthroscopy with drilling through the subchondral bone was performed within 2 months of the injury in four patients with subchondral fractures of the talus. In 16 patients, conservative treatment was given, and in three patients the treatment was unknown.

Twenty of the 23 patients had follow-up imaging. MR imaging performed in two patients with kissing contusions showed persistence of the tibial lesions. In one of these patients, the lesion was still seen at 1-month follow-up, and in the other patient, complete resolution occurred after 10 months. MR imaging performed in two patients with kissing lesions (an osteochondral fracture of the talus and a contusion of the tibia) showed complete healing 11 months after the initial injury in one patient and minimal residual edema in the talus 17 months after the injury in the other patient. CT arthrography performed in one patient with a solitary talus fracture showed that the fracture was still visible after 7 months. Radiography in 15 patients with 12 kissing and three solitary lesions showed osteochondral fractures of the talus in three patients and no evidence of subchondral injury in the others from 1 month to 2 years after the initial injury.

Discussion

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 
MR imaging is a highly sensitive modality for examining the subchondral tissues after injury [4], 9]. A variety of changes can occur after trauma, ranging from bone bruises or contusions to osteochondral fractures. The bone bruises are thought to represent trabecular microcontusions associated with hemorrhage, edema, and hyperemia [7]. On MR images, the bruises present as relatively ill-defined semicircular areas of abnormal signal intensity in the subcortical bone that do not extend through the cortex [7]. When a fracture is also present, disruption of the cortical bone is seen as a low-signal-intensity line extending through the cortical surface on T2-weighted images. The subchondral abnormalities are believed to be the result of trauma causing impaction of the bones. In the ankle, additional rotational forces may contribute to the mechanism of injury [10]. It has been reported that bone bruises occurred in 7% of the ankles after a first-time sprain [11]. The higher incidence of bone bruises after recurrent sprains suggests that reinjury may play an important role in their occurrence [11]. Bone contusions in the ankle are often associated with ligamentous injury [12]. On the other hand, bone contusions may occur in the absence of major ligament disruptions [11]. Knee bone contusions are known to resolve in 1-4 months after injury. We found some cases of edema in the ankle persisting for a longer period of time. This persistence may suggest that the time necessary for healing in the ankle is longer. On the other hand, ankle instability due to ligamentous injury and recurrent sprains may also be responsible for the persisting bone marrow edema in the ankle. The healing period of the osteochondral injury in the ankle therefore still remains unknown [11, 13].

We found 42 osteochondral lesions in our series of 146 patients. Of these lesions, there were 36 bone contusions. The frequency of the findings is well within the range (6.5-39%) reported in the literature [13, 14]. However, the number of patients (11%) with kissing lesions was much higher than that reported by others. For instance, Labovitz and Schweitzer [13] found kissing lesions in only five (5%) of 109 patients. It is unclear why the number of kissing lesions was relatively high in our series. However, a large proportion of patients (17/23) with subchondral injury consisted of personnel of the military forces, individuals in whom osteochondral lesions are more likely to occur [5, 14]. In the patients with kissing lesions, we found that all osteochondral fractures were located in the talus, whereas the contusions were predominantly seen in the tibial plafond. There are several potential explanations for the higher occurrence of the subchondral fractures in the talus than in the tibiofibular plafond. First, osteochondral lesions are more commonly observed at the convex surface of a joint, whereas the concave surface is generally spared. The convex surface is believed to transmit the forces (convergence of force) toward a central focus, whereas a concave surface dissipates the forces. As a result, the concave joint surface, such as that of the talus, is likely to be more severely damaged by trauma than the tibial plafond [10]. Second, the cartilage of the tibia is stiffer than that of the talus because of differences in composition [15]. In six of the 16 kissing lesions, the abnormalities were directly opposite each other; therefore, it is likely that the lesions of the tibiofibular plafond were the result of direct impaction of the talar bone onto the opposing tibial bone. In the remaining 10 kissing lesions, the lesions were not diametrically opposed probably because rotation occurred during the injury [7].

A shortcoming of our study was the limited follow-up with MR imaging. In the one patient in whom CT was performed, no changes were noted in the osteochondral fractures after 7 months. No osteochondral lesions were seen in any of 15 patients who had radiographic followup. However, the latter technique is insensitive in detecting these lesions. Thus, the changes over time of bone contusions in the ankle remain uncertain. Nevertheless, the clinical significance of bone contusions in the ankle has not been established, and it has been suggested that these contusions do not need to be treated [9]. Osteochondral fractures, on the other hand, do need to be treated with reduced weight-bearing for an extended period of time [11]. A further shortcoming of our study was the retrospective study design. Because of the large number of military recruits, our study was subject to selection bias. This bias makes it difficult to extrapolate these findings to a general orthopedic practice.

In conclusion, we found a relatively high number of subchondral injuries (11%) involving the subchondral bone of the talus and tibia. Of these kissing lesions, bone contusions were most commonly seen in the tibial plafond, and osteochondral fractures were most often seen in the talar dome. The kissing lesions are most likely caused by impaction of the talus onto the tibia with or without torsion.

References

Top Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results Discussion References

 

1. Anderson IF, Crichton KJ, Grattan-Smith T, Cooper RA, Brazier D. Osteochondral contusions of the dome of the talus. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1989;71-A:1143 -1152[Abstract/Free Full Text]
2. Ferkel RD. Articular surface defects, loose bodies, and osteophytes. In: Ferkel RD. Arthroscopic surgery: the foot and ankle, 1 st ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven, 1996: 145-184
3. Ly PN, Fallat M. Transchondral contusions of the talus: a review of 64 surgical cases. J Foot Surg 1993;32:352 -374
4. Schweitzer ME. Magnetic resonance imaging of the foot and ankle. Magn Reson Q 1993;9:214 -234[Medline]
5. Berndt AL, Harty M. Transchondral contusion (osteochondritis dissecans) of the talus. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1959;41-A:988 -1020[Abstract/Free Full Text]
6. Lundeen RO. Ankle arthroscopy in the adolescent patient. J Foot Surg 1990;29:510 -515[Medline]
7. Kaplan PA, Craig WW, Kilcoyne RF, Brown DE, Tusek D, Dussault RG. Occult fracture patterns of the knee associated with anterior cruciate ligament tears: assessment with MR imaging. Radiology 1992;183:835 -838[Abstract/Free Full Text]
8. Canosa J. Mirror image osteochondral defects of the talus and distal tibia. Int Orthop 1994;18:395 -396[Medline]
9. Magee TH, Hinson GW. Usefulness of MR imaging in the detection of talar dome injuries. AJR 1998;170:1227 -1230[Abstract/Free Full Text]
10. Camasta CA, Pitts TE, Corey SV. Bilateral osteochondritis dissecans of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc 1994;84:297 -310[Abstract]
11. Pinar H, Akseki D, Kovanlikaya I, Arac S, Bozkurt M. Bone bruises detected by magnetic resonance imaging following lateral ankle sprains. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 1997;5:113 -117[Medline]
12. Nishimura G, Yamato M, Togawa M. Trabecular trauma of the talus and medial malleolus concurrent with lateral collateral ligamentous injuries of the ankle: evaluation with MR imaging. Skeletal Radiol 1996;25:49 -54[Medline]
13. Labovitz JM, Schweitzer ME. Occult osseous injuries after ankle sprains: incidence, location, pattern, and age. Foot Ankle 1998;19:661 -667[Medline]
14. Flick AB, Gould N. Osteochondritis dissecans of the talus (transchondral fractures of the talus): review of the literature and new surgical approach for medial dome lesions. Foot Ankle 1985;5:165 -185[Medline]
15. Athanasiou KA, Niederauer NG, Schenck RC. Biomechanical topography of human ankle cartilage. Ann Biomed Eng 1995;23:697 -704[Medline]

CiteULike

Complore

Connotea

Del.icio.us

Digg

Reddit

Technorati

This article has been cited by other articles:

				S Ostlere Imaging the ankle Imaging, September 1, 2007; 19(3): 269 - 298. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. A. W. Verhagen, M. Maas, M. G. W. Dijkgraaf, J. L. Tol, R. Krips, and C. N. van Dijk Prospective study on diagnostic strategies in osteochondral lesions of the talus: IS MRI SUPERIOR TO HELICAL CT? J Bone Joint Surg Br, January 1, 2005; 87-B(1): 41 - 46. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				S Ostlere Imaging the ankle and foot Imaging, December 1, 2003; 15(4): 242 - 269. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

This Article Abstract Figures Only Full Text (PDF) Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Similar articles in PubMed Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Sijbrandij, E. S. Articles by de Lange, E. E. Search for Related Content PubMed PubMed Citation Articles by Sijbrandij, E. S. Articles by de Lange, E. E. Social Bookmarking                      What's this?