|
|
||||||||
Original Research |
1 All authors: Department of Radiology, Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, 396C Main Building, 111 S 10th St., Philadelphia, PA 19107.
Received November 8, 2004;
accepted after revision January 31, 2005.
Address correspondence to D. Bergin
(diane.bergin{at}jefferson.edu).
Abstract
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS. One hundred forty-two MRI examinations with full-thickness supraspinatus tendon tears were categorized on the basis of the supraspinatus muscle (SS): normal muscle (SSnormal), suggesting a recent or small tear; reduced muscle bulk without fatty atrophy (SSvolume loss); and those with fatty atrophy, suggesting a large or chronic tear (SSfatty atrophy). Subscapularis tendon abnormalities, the subcoracoid interval, and subcortical bone marrow edema in the lesser tuberosity and coracoid process were recorded.
RESULTS. The mean size of supraspinatus tendon tears in the SSnormal (n = 45) group was 8.5 mm, 16.6 mm in SSvolume loss (n = 53), and 29 mm in the SSfatty atrophy group (n = 44). Subscapularis tendon abnormality was identified in 22% of SSnormal patients, 61% of SSvolume loss, and 86% of the SSfatty atrophy group (p < 0.001). There was moderate correlation between chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tears and subscapularis tendon abnormality (r = 0.47; p < 0.0001), with no correlation between the subcoracoid interval and abnormalities of the subscapularis tendon. There was moderate correlation between chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tears and bone marrow changes in the lesser tuberosity (r = 0.44; p < 0.0001).
CONCLUSION. Subscapularis tendon abnormality is related to chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tears. Bone marrow edema in the lesser tuberosity with a subscapularis tendon abnormality suggests increased stress at the subscapularis tendon insertion with chronicity of full-thickness supraspinatus tendon tears. Lack of correlation with the subcoracoid interval indicates that anterior instability may be a more important contributing factor to subscapularis tendon abnormalities than static subcoracoid impingement in the setting of a full-thickness supraspinatus tendon tear.
Keywords: MRI musculoskeletal imaging shoulder subscapularis tendon supraspinatus tendon
|
|
|---|
In this study, we sought to determine the relationship between size and chronicity of full-thickness tears of the supraspinatus tendon with abnormalities of the subscapularis tendon. As subcoracoid impingement can be associated with subscapularis abnormalities, we also noted if objective MRI signs were seen that suggested coexistent subcoracoid impingement in this population group.
|
|
|---|
MRI studies were performed using a 1.5-T unit (Signa, GE Healthcare) with a dedicated shoulder coil, 14-cm field of view, 4-mm section thickness with a 1-mm gap, and 256 x 256 matrix. All patients were imaged in a supine position with their arm by their side, thumb pointing upward. Sequences performed were sagittal oblique T2-weighted fast spin echo (TR/effective TE, 2,500-6,000/80-90; echo-train length, 8), coronal oblique T1-weighted spin echo (400-800/8-12), coronal oblique T2-weighted fast spin echo (2,500-6,000/60-80; fat suppressed; echo-train length, 8), and axial T2-weighted fast spin echo (2,500-6,000/60-80; fat suppressed; echo-train length, 8).
Two radiologists in consensus reviewed the images. The most medial sagittal oblique T2-weighted image was used to assess supraspinatus muscle bulk relative to other rotator cuff muscles. T1-weighted coronal oblique images were used to assess muscles for fatty atrophy. MRI examinations were rated on a three-point ordinal scale: normal supraspinatus muscle (SSnormal), loss of volume of supraspinatus muscle without evidence of muscle atrophy (SSvolume loss), and muscle atrophy (SSfatty atrophy).
The anteroposterior dimension of the rotator cuff tear was measured using sagittal oblique T2-weighted images. Tears or tendonosis of the infraspinatus, teres minor, and subscapularis tendons were noted when present. Tendonosis was defined as ill-defined increased T2 signal in the tendon but less than water signal [5]. A tear was defined as discontinuity of tendon fibers with increased T2 signal in the tendon and isointense with water signal [5-7]. A full-thickness tear was defined as disruption of tendon fibers extending from the superior (bursal) to the inferior (undersurface) surface of the tendon by fluid signal. Partial-thickness tears were defined as focal disruption of the tendon by fluid signal but not extending to both tendon surfaces.
The presence of subcortical bone marrow edema or cyst formation in the coracoid or lesser tuberosity was assessed on T2-weighted images. In each study, the subcoracoid interval was measured on axial images. The narrowest distance between the coracoid process and the lesser tuberosity was recorded.
We calculated the incidence and type of subscapularis tendon abnormality in each subgroup: SSnormal, SSvolume loss, and SSfatty atrophy.We also determined the incidence of tears or tendonosis of the infraspinatus and teres minor tendons. For these incidence percentages we calculated the 95% confidence interval per standard statistical formulae [8]. We examined the relationship of subscapularis tendon abnormality with the chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tear and the presence of subcortical edema or cyst formation in the coracoid process and lesser tuberosity using Spearman's correlation test (r). We performed a one-way analysis variance test to determine the relationship between subscapularis tendon abnormality with subcoracoid interval and extent of supraspinatus tear, and we tested pairwise comparisons with Bonferroni t tests.
|
|
|---|
|
The mean anteroposterior dimension of the rotator cuff tear was 8.5 mm in the SSnormal group, 16.6 mm in the SSvolume loss group, and 29 mm in the SSfatty atrophy group. Anteroposterior measurement of rotator cuff tear was within the 1- to 14-mm range in 42 (93%) patients in the SSnormal group, 21(40%) in the SSvolume loss group, and seven (16%) in the SSfatty atrophy group. Anteroposterior measurement of rotator cuff tear was within the 15- to 47-mm range in three (7%) patients in the SSnormal group, 32 (60%) in the SSvolume loss group, and 37 (84%) in the SSfatty atrophy group. There was a correlation of 0.67 (p < 0.001) between chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tear as manifested by the status of the supraspinatus muscle on MRI and anteroposterior extent of tear.
Within the SSnormal group, 35 (78%) patients had a normal subscapularis tendon, five (11%) had subscapularis tendonosis, two (4%) had partial tears of the subscapularis tendon, and three (7%) had full-thickness tears of the subscapularis tendon (Figs. 1A and 1B). Within the SSvolume loss group, 21 (40%) patients had a normal subscapularis tendon, 17 (32%) had subscapularis tendonosis, 10 (19%) had a partial tear of the subscapularis tendon (Figs. 2A and 2B), and five (9%) had full-thickness tears of the subscapularis tendon. Of the SSfatty atrophy group, six (14%) patients had a normal subscapularis tendon, 15 (34%) had subscapularis tendonosis (Figs. 3A, 3B, and 3C), 19 (43%) had partial tears of the subscapularis tendon, and four (9%) had full-thickness tears of the subscapularis tendon. There was moderate correlation (r = 0.47; p < 0.001) between severity of the subscapularis tendon as observed by MRI and chronicity of full-thickness supraspinatus tendon tear manifested by supraspinatus muscle changes.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The mean subcoracoid interval was 9.3 mm (range, 5-18 mm) in examinations with a normal subscapularis tendon, 9 mm (range, 5-15 mm) in those with subscapularis tendonosis, 8 mm (range, 3-17 mm) in those with partial tears, and 7.5 mm (range, 1-19 mm) in those with full-thickness tears of the subscapularis tendon. There was no significant correlation (p > 0.05) between the subcoracoid interval and degree of abnormality of the subscapularis tendon.
Bone marrow changes in the lesser tuberosity were seen in two (4%) patients in the SSnormal group, 19 (36%) in the SSvolume loss group, and 25 (57%) in the SSfatty atrophy group. There was a significant relationship between chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tear and presence of bone marrow changes in the lesser tuberosity (r = 0.44; p < 0.0001).
There was subcortical edema and cyst formation in the lesser tuberosity in one (2%) patient with a normal subscapularis tendon, 17 (46%) with subscapularis tendonosis, 22 (71%) with partial tears, and seven (58%) with full-thickness tears of the subscapularis tendon. There was a significant relationship between abnormality of the subscapularis tendon and the presence of lesser tuberosity edema and cyst formation (r = 0.58; p < 0.0001).
There was no subcortical bone marrow edema or cyst formation in the coracoid process in any examination reviewed in this population group.
In this series, 42 (29.6%) of 142 patients had infraspinatus tendonosis, 34 (23.9%) had partial-thickness tendon tears, and 44 (31.0%) had full-thickness tendon tears of the infraspinatus. No teres minor tendon tears were identified. Ten cases (7.0%) of teres minor muscle atrophy were seen.
|
|
|---|
Previous studies have reported subscapularis tendon tears in 2% of rotator cuff tears [1]. In our study, the overall incidence of subscapularis tendon tears associated with full-thickness tears of the supraspinatus tendon was 8.4%, higher than previously reported. Overall, 80 (56.3%) patients with full-thickness tears of the supraspinatus tendon had abnormality of the subscapularis tendon on MRI. Forty-three (30%) patients with full-thickness tears of the supraspinatus tendon had associated tears of the subscapularis tendon (22% partial, 8% complete). There was a significant correlation between chronicity and severity of supraspinatus tendon tear with presence of subscapularis tendon abnormality. To our knowledge, no report in the radiology literature has evaluated this relationship.
Subcoracoid impingement is caused by entrapment of a portion of the rotator cuff between the coracoid process and the head of the humerus [15]. Gerber et al. [15] determined that positioning of the shoulder to 90-100° forward flexion and internal rotation significantly decreases the distance between the coracoid and the humeral head (8.7 vs 6.8 mm). Reported MRI signs associated with subcoracoid impingement include subcortical bone marrow edema of the coracoid process and lesser tuberosity associated with reduced subcoracoid interval. Friedman et al. [16] described significant reduction of normal space between the humeral head and the coracoid process in symptomatic patients relative to a healthy population with cine MRI and shoulders positioned in maximal internal rotation. They reported that the average coracohumeral distance in the asymptomatic patient was 11 mm [16]. Although the mean subcoracoid interval of our study population was 8 mm (range, 5-15 mm), no significant relationship was found between the measured subcoracoid interval and severity of subscapularis tendon abnormality.
In this study, images were obtained in the neutral position, allowing assessment of static subcoracoid impingement only. No bone marrow edema or cyst formation in the coracoid process was seen in our study population. Overall, 58% of patients with subscapularis tendon abnormalities had bone marrow edema or cyst formation in the lesser tuberosity and only 2% of patients with a normal subscapularis tendon had bone marrow edema in the lesser tuberosity. Significant correlation was found between the incidence of bone marrow edema and cyst formation in the lesser tuberosity with severity of abnormality of the subscapularis tendon and chronicity of tear of the supraspinatus tendon. To our knowledge. this has never been reported in the radiology literature. One potential explanation for this finding is that with a torn and thus dysfunctional supraspinatus tendon, the normal depressor function on the humeral head is insufficient, giving rise to abnormal mechanical stress on the subscapularis tendon insertion.
Recent surgical literature has suggested the contribution of subcoracoid impingement on rotator cuff dysfunction [17-21]. Suenaga et al. [17] reported persistent pain in patients after rotator cuff repair because of persistent subcoracoid impingement. They concluded that subcoracoid impingement is a potential cause of unsuccessful rotator cuff surgery and recommended coracoplasty in patients with subcoracoid impingement after management of rotator cuff tear [17]. Lo et al. [18, 20] recently reported successful postoperative results in patients who had one-step arthroscopic treatment for subcoracoid and subacromial impingement. However, our findings suggest that static distance between the coracoid and lesser tuberosity is not responsible for the majority of subscapularis tendon abnormalities in this group of patients. Either true subcoracoid impingement is a rare entity or it is anterior shoulder instability that is the true causative factor, creating a dynamic phenomenon related to anterior humeral head subluxation. Lack of corresponding "kissing" marrow changes in the coracoid process argues against static subcoracoid impingement as a cause of subscapularis abnormalities. Subtendinous edema at the lesser tuberosity suggests that with progressive chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tear, there is increase in anterior instability, giving rise to greater mechanical stress by the anterior humeral head on the undersurface fibers of the subscapularis tendon, leading to tendonosis and subsequent tear. Preoperative MRI should evaluate not only for subacromial impingement but also for marrow changes in the region of the lesser tuberosity to allow definitive treatment at surgery and reduce incidence of persistent dysfunction and pain postoperatively. To assess for anterior instability and positional reduction in the subcoracoid interval, dynamic MRI or images obtained in both the neutral and internally rotated positions should be obtained. This is an entity for potential research in this population group.
This study is limited by the lack of clinical and surgical correlation. However, as this was a retrospective study and our referral base was very broad, it was not possible to obtain patient clinical records. Also, lack of standardized clinical assessment would limit the reliability of clinical findings. As the subscapularis tendon is not routinely evaluated at arthroscopy, correlation with surgical reports was not performed.
Selection bias and absence of a control group also limited this study. Using muscle and fat replacement as an analog for tear chronicity has its limitations. However, it is difficult to directly document the onset of rotator cuff tear and we think this is a satisfactory solution. Nevertheless, this study shows a significant relationship between chronicity of full-thickness supraspinatus tendon tears and severity of subscapularis tendon abnormality. It shows a clear relationship between presence of bone marrow edema in the lesser tuberosity with severity and chronicity of supraspinatus tendon tear, suggesting that secondary anterior instability predisposes to subsequent subscapularis tendon abnormality.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
U. Studler, C. W. A. Pfirrmann, B. Jost, V. Rousson, J. Hodler, and M. Zanetti Abnormalities of the Lesser Tuberosity on Radiography and MRI: Association with Subscapularis Tendon Lesions Am. J. Roentgenol., July 1, 2008; 191(1): 100 - 106. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |