|
|
||||||||
Original Research |
1 Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public
Health, E3/311 Clinical Science Center, 600 Highland Ave., Madison, WI
53792-3252.
2 Department of Orthopedics and Rehabilitation, University of Wisconsin School
of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI.
3 Department of Pathology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public
Health, Madison, WI.
Received June 6, 2007;
accepted after revision July 10, 2007.
WEB This is a Web exclusive article.
Abstract
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS. We performed serial MRI of 16 knees of eight swine with one nontraumatized knee as a control and 15 knees traumatized by direct patellar impact injuries using a force-calibrated device. All knees were imaged on a 1.5-T scanner using an 8-channel phased-array coil with T1-weighted, fat-saturated T2-weighted and STIR sequences. Scanning was performed at 1, 6, 12, and 30 hours after impact injury. Two radiologists independently reviewed each MR examination to identify MR signal intensity changes in the patellae and adjacent femoral condyles.
RESULTS. In the 15 traumatized knees, bone bruises were noted in 93% of the patellae on T1-weighted images and in 87% of the patellae on fluid-sensitive MR images at 1 hour after injury and in 100% of the patellae at 6 hours. T1-weighted images were insensitive for detection of bone bruises in the femoral condyles. Bone bruises in the femoral condyles were seen on fluid-sensitive MR sequences as early as 1 hour after injury, with an increasing frequency over the 30-hour period.
CONCLUSION. Bone bruises can be seen as soon as 1 hour after trauma but may not be seen until 30 hours after trauma. Fluid-sensitive (fat-saturated, T2-weighted, and STIR) MR sequences are more sensitive than T1-weighted images in the detection of bone bruises.
Keywords: bone bruise knee MRI
|
|
|---|
Recently, we performed MRI on an athlete 2 hours after traumatic hip subluxation, and the findings revealed a posterior labral tear with hip effusion but no bone abnormality (Fig. 1A). A subsequent MRI performed 3 months later to confirm healing of the labral tear revealed an anterosuperior bone marrow abnormality (Fig. 1B). We were uncertain as to whether the abnormality at 3 months after the injury was a persistent delayed-onset bone bruise or an area of osteonecrosis. Clinical and MR follow-up documented clearing of the MR abnormality within 6 months and completely normal hip function and radiographic appearance at 2 years after the injury. Because of the clinical importance of this differential diagnosis, we developed an animal model for a bone bruise and used this model to determine the timing of MR changes in the bone marrow after bone injury.
|
|
|
|
|---|
Ten crossbred female swine from a commercial vendor (University of Wisconsin Arlington Farms) (mean weight, 51 kg; range, 45-57 kg; mean age, 11 weeks; age range, 10-12 weeks) were used for this study. Adolescent swine were chosen on the basis of size so they could be moved multiple times while sedated. We decided to use the swine knee to develop our model for bone bruises because of the size of this joint in a swine and its morphologic similarity to the human knee. We specifically selected the patellofemoral joint for study because striking the anterior surface of the patella allowed more precise measurement of the impacting force than could be achieved in a model that attempted to reproduce the clinically common femorotibial bone bruises such as seen in anterior cruciate ligament injuries. Selection of the patella as the point of impact was also advantageous because it provided a site with a direct contusion, the patella, and a site with transmitted osteochondral forces, the femoral trochlea.
|
|
Method for Impacting Patella
Before beginning the MR portion of the study, we designed a pneumatically
accelerated mass system to impact the swine patella. This concept was our
adaptation of the system used by Atkinson and Haut
[7]. The pneumatic system
allowed more flexibility than a drop-weight system to control the final energy
and velocity of the accelerated mass. By adjusting the acceleration chamber
length (via adjustable stops) and the mass of the impactor, a very wide range
of impact energies and final velocities was available. We used a high-velocity
impact to minimize the possibility of strain-induced fracture of the patella.
The basic system (Fig. 2)
consisted of a cylindric impactor mass (252 g) with polytetrafluoroethylene
bearings (Fig. 3), an
acceleration chamber fitted with optical sensors to measure final velocity, an
electrically operated high-flow-rate valve, and a pressure chamber with a
digital pressure gauge to monitor chamber pressure.
Pressure was applied to the pressure chamber via a pressure regulator and a ball valve and was read via the digital gauge to ± 0.1 psi (0.69 kPa). Pressure was released by a small switch and a battery. Once released, the mass accelerated down the acceleration chamber, where it interrupted two light beams separated by a precise distance, thereby allowing an accurate measure of the final velocity. The impactor then hit a custom-fabricated load cell positioned between the knee and the impactor. Using custom signal conditioning, load versus time data were relayed to a digital oscilloscope (TDS1012, Tektronix) and saved for later analysis. Analysis of the data was done with Microsoft Excel, and the resulting load data were plotted versus time.
The pneumatically accelerated mass system was then tested on one swine before beginning the study (two knees) to determine the force that could be applied without visible fracturing (shattering) of the patella. To place the device accurately, a skin incision was made directly over the patella, which allowed palpation and marking of the patella. The size of the impaction device was approximately one half the size of the swine patella.
Before animal testing, a certified animal care technician sedated the swine with tiletamine hydrochloride and zolazepam hydrochloride 7 mg/kg (Telazol IM, Fort Dodge Animal Health), xylazine 2.2 mg/kg IM (Xyla-Ject, Phoenix Pharmaceutical), atropine sulfate 0.05 mg/kg IM. IV access was established in each swine's ear vein. Propofol 2-8 mg/kg was used if additional sedation was needed for intubation. Maintenance of anesthesia throughout the procedure was by inhaled 1-3% isoflurane via a 5.0-7.5 endotracheal tube. A dose of buprenorphine 0.005-0.01 mg/kg IM was given before the start of bone injury followed by a second dose given at 1-6 hours after trauma as needed to maintain analgesia at the site of surgery until the animal was sacrificed.
After the initial development of the device for impacting the patella, we then studied both knees of eight swine, of which 15 were traumatized and one used as our control. All 15 knees were incised for accurate placement of the impaction device. Both the patella and distal femur were evaluated for bone injury due to both direct and indirect injury causing the bone bruise.
MRI Studies
After the patellar impaction injury, the animals were immediately taken to
the MR scanner for imaging. All 16 animal knees were imaged on a 1.5-T magnet
using an 8-channel phased-array coil. All animals were positioned supine with
the coil centered over the knee joint. This was the best position for imaging
because the coil was centered over the knees and because of the anesthesia.
The sedation and anesthesia protocols used for imaging were identical to those
used during the creation of the knee injury. The following sequences were
performed: axial and sagittal T1 (TR/TE, 500/20), fat-saturated fast spin-echo
T2 (2,200/76; echotrain length, 3), and fast spin-echo STIR (3,000/48;
inversion time, 160). Coronal fast spin-echo STIR (3,000/50; inversion time,
160) sequences were also performed along the long axis of the femur. A 16-cm
field of view; matrix, 256-320 x 224-256; number of excitations, 2; and
3-mm thickness with 0.5-mm gap were used for all sequences. Scanning was
performed immediately (completed within 1 hour after injury; average time,
30-40 minutes), 6, 12, and 30 hours after trauma. Because of cost and research
scanner access, we were not able to obtain scans at hourly intervals.
Our initial animal was scanned out to 12 hours with subsequent animals scanned out to 30 hours. Two animals died after the 12-hour scan; another died after the 6-hour scan; only the right knee in one animal was imaged at the 6-hour time frame, with the left knee not imaged after the initial 1-hour scan.
Two musculoskeletal radiologists independently reviewed each MR examination documenting patellar and femoral signal intensity changes and then resolved differences in interpretation by consensus reading. Each patella and the trochlear portions of the distal femoral condyles were subjectively evaluated for changes in the MR appearance of the marrow from the normal appearance of adolescent swine knees on the T1-weighted, fatsaturated T2-weighted, and STIR images. The T1-weighted and fluid-sensitive sequences were read independently of each other. The readers were not blinded to the timing of the images.
Histologic Studies
After the final MRI, the knee joints were removed after the animals were
sacrificed. After fixation with 10% formalin, the femurs were cut
longitudinally with a band saw slightly anterior to the midline. The femurs
and patellae were subsequently decalcified, and two coronal sections from the
distal femur and two transverse sections from the midportion of the patellae
were submitted for paraffin embedding. Histologic sections were cut at 4 µm
in thickness, stained with H and E, and evaluated for the presence of
trabecular microfractures, hemorrhage, and edema. The location of the sections
used for histologic examination was chosen by estimating the site of the
patellar impact on the distal femur.
The edema in the histologic specimens was measured by estimating the fraction of edema in the marrow space. This was done with low-power examination of the slide by estimating the acellular area on the slide because edema histologically appears as a separation of cells. The edema on each slide was estimated twice by the same reviewer at different times to ensure internal consistency. Histologically, edema is represented by a separation of, or space between, the hematopoietic cells of the bone marrow space. We attempted to exclude artifact "separation of cells" by identifying edema that was accompanied by fibrin, proteinaceous debris, and extravasated RBCs.
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
Patella—Both the T1-weighted and fluid-weighted sequences were sensitive in identifying findings of a patellar bone bruise soon after the injury (Fig. 6). Low-signal abnormality on T1-weighted images was seen in 93% (13/14) of the patellae and high-signal abnormality in 87% (13/15) of the patellae on fluid-weighted MR sequences obtained within 1 hour of the injury (Fig. 7A, 7B). All patellae had both T1-weighted and fluid-weighted MR abnormalities at 6 hours after the injury. These changes persisted at 12 and 30 hours after the injury except for one patella at 30 hours in which the signal abnormality was no longer seen on either T1-weighted or fluid-sensitive sequences. An increase in low signal intensity over time was seen in six of the patellae and an increase in high signal on the fluid-sensitive sequences in 10 patellae. An overview of the results is provided in Table 1.
|
|
|
|
Femoral condyles—Unlike the situation in the patellae, a low-signal abnormality in the femoral condyles was noted on T1-weighted images in only one knee at the 1-, 6-, and 12-hour intervals after the injury and in 29% (2/7) of the knees imaged at 30 hours after the injury. In contrast, the fluid-weighted MR sequences had a high-signal abnormality in 33% (5/15) on the examination performed within 1 hour of the injury (Fig. 8A, 8B). The frequency of MR abnormality then steadily increased until the 30-hour examination when 100% (6/6) of the femurs showed a high-signal abnormality. An increase in high signal intensity over time was seen in nine femurs on the fluid-sensitive sequences. No change in T1 low signal intensity was detected within the femurs. An overview of the results is provided in Table 1.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|
The clinical significance of our study goes back to the question in the evaluation of our patient who had a traumatic injury to the hip. We had originally assumed that a bone bruise should be seen on an MR image obtained 2 hours after the injury. Thus we thought that the signal abnormality noted on the MR image had to represent osteonecrosis. However, the location of the MR abnormality on the anterosuperior aspect of the femoral head was not a typical appearance or location for osteonecrosis. In fact, this location suggested a bone injury suffered during reduction of a presumed posterior hip subluxation similar to the humeral head Hill-Sachs injury in an anterior shoulder dislocation. On the basis of our animal study showing that a bone bruise may not be visible on MRI for more than 12 hours after injury, we now think that our patient had a slowly resolving bone bruise rather than osteonecrosis.
Our results indicate that after a high-impact direct bone injury such as the patellae in our model, a bone bruise is present approximately 90% of the time on either T1-weighted or fluid-sensitive MR sequences done within 1 hour after the injury and at 100% at 6 hours after injury. However, with lesser-impact-force injuries across an osteochondral surface, such as the femoral condyle in our model, a bone bruise may take more than 12 hours to appear on a fluid sequence. In our study, all six swine femoral condyles that were imaged at 30 hours showed a bone bruise pattern on a fluid-weighted MR sequence.
We also found that both T1-weighted imaging and fluid-sensitive imaging (fat-saturated T2-weighted or STIR) were nearly equally sensitive in the detection of high-impact-injury bone bruises in the patellae. However, fluid-sensitive MR sequences were more sensitive than T1-weighted images in the detection of bone bruises within the femoral condyles. We hypothesize that the MRI findings were more apparent in the patella than in the femoral condyles because the patellar injuries were more severe due to the direct bone impact on to the patella. In contrast, the injuries of the condyles were likely of a lower impact force because the chondral surfaces of the patella and femur diffused the forces impacting the femoral condyles. The greater sensitivity of fluid-weighted sequences for marrow abnormality when compared with T1-weighted images is well documented [1, 3-5, 13, 14].
To our knowledge, there has been one previous study on an animal model of bone bruises [15] in swine. In this study, a small metal hammer was used to create a bone bruise of the medial aspect of the proximal tibia. The authors did not quantify the force on the tibia. Each tibia was struck with a hammer until the cortex of the tibia was mildly depressed. The animals were imaged immediately after surgery and biweekly until they were sacrificed. They did not determine when bone bruises first appeared.
We found that fat-saturated T2-weighted and STIR imaging were comparable in detection of bone marrow edema. In only one femoral condyle did we find edema on the STIR images that was not detected on the fat-saturated T2-weighted images. This finding agrees with a previous study evaluating bone contusions of the knee comparing fat-saturated T2-weighted and STIR images in which a comparable sensitivity and specificity were found for the two pulse sequences [1]. In that study, STIR imaging had slightly increased lesion conspicuity, whereas T2-weighted fat-saturated images showed slightly improved overall subjective image quality. We agree with their assessment that when rapid detection of bone contusions is desired or when a lesion is suspected, STIR imaging is preferable over fat-saturated T2-weighted imaging. However, we did not find that fat-saturated T2-weighted imaging had improved subjective image quality. This difference between the findings of the previous study and ours likely reflects improvement in MR image quality in the 10 years since their study.
Histologic analysis of the knees showed marrow edema within all of the traumatized patellae and adjacent femurs but no marrow abnormalities in the nontraumatized knee. We were surprised to find that hemorrhage was noted histologically in only two of the traumatized patellae and three of the traumatized femurs. In addition, no trabecular microfractures were found. Our histologic findings support the findings reported in the literature of the histology of a bone bruise. At histopathologic examination in MR-documented bone bruises, microfractures of cancellous bone, edema, and hemorrhage were also identified [6, 15].
Our study has a number of limitations. First, we were not able to image all of the animals at all intervals because of the death of several animals during the study. We kept the animals under analgesic sedation after the impact injury per the requirement of our animal care committee. This continuous sedation likely contributed to the deaths, which occurred before the scheduled delayed scanning at 30 hours. Second, because of the practical aspects of research scanner access and the need for anesthesia during MRI, we were not able to obtain scans at hourly intervals. Thus when an MR abnormality was not noted at 1 hour but was seen at 6 hours, we cannot be certain when the MR abnormality appeared during the 1- to 6-hour interval. Third, we did not evaluate whether there might be additional MR abnormalities that occurred later than the 30-hour MR image. Fourth, we did not obtain a pretrauma MR image in every knee; however, it is unlikely that the juvenile swine would have preexisting bone contusions.
In conclusion, our study showed that in an animal model, MRI can depict early changes in bone marrow resulting from direct and indirect injury to bone. Both direct and indirect bone bruises are usually present on MRI performed at 12 hours after trauma but may be delayed up to 30 hours. Clinically, if an MR examination is performed too soon after trauma and is negative for injury, with the patient having continued pain or limitations, a follow-up MRI may be useful 5-7 days after trauma.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully thank Kimberly Mauer, Experimental Surgery,
University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health for the expert
assistance in sedation and care of our swine during this project. The authors
also thank Kelli Hellenbrand, MR research technologist, Department of
Radiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health for
assistance in scanning our subjects. We also thank Ben Graf, Professor of
Orthopedics and Rehabilitation, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and
Public Health, for his advice and input before beginning this project.
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |