|
|
||||||||
Original Research |
1 Department of Radiology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA
02114.
2 Present address: Department of Radiology, Boston Medical Center, 820 Harrison
Ave., FGH Bldg. 3rd Fl., Boston, MA 02118.
Received February 8, 2008;
accepted after revision June 5, 2008.
Address correspondence to A. Saokar Rebello.
Abstract
|
|
|---|
MATERIALS AND METHODS. A search of an interventional radiology database identified 85 transvaginal drainage procedures on 67 patients. Pertinent medical records and images were reviewed. Clinical success was defined as no need for surgery.
RESULTS. The mean follow-up period was 36.6 months (range, 7 days–132 months). Forty-five aspiration and 40 catheter drainage procedures were performed on 67 patients. Indications for the procedures included postoperative fluid collection (n = 25), tuboovarian abscess unresponsive to medical therapy (n = 17), symptomatic ovarian cyst (n = 17), and miscellaneous causes (n = 8). Clinical success was achieved in 50 of 67 cases (75%), including all cases of 25 postoperative fluid collection, 12 of 17 tuboovarian abscesses (71%), and seven of 17 ovarian cysts (41%). No complications were found in patients who underwent aspiration alone. The following minor complications occurred in patients who underwent catheter drainage: two cases of bladder transgression, one case of infection, and one case of catheter-related pain. Premature dislodgment of the catheter was an issue for four of 40 patients (10%).
CONCLUSION. Postoperative fluid collections can be managed with a high rate of success by means of transvaginal aspiration or catheter drainage. Transvaginal catheter drainage is an alternative to surgery in the management of tuboovarian abscesses unresponsive to medical management. Aspiration alone is sufficient to drain ovarian cysts and provide symptomatic relief. Most cysts recur, however, ultimately necessitating surgery. Aspiration is safe, but catheter drainage is associated with a 10% rate of minor complications.
Keywords: drainage pelvis transvaginal sonography
|
|
|---|
Interventional radiologists can gain access to pelvic fluid collections by the anterior trans abdominal, transgluteal, endo rectal, and transvaginal routes [1–8]. The anterior percutaneous transabdominal approach is prefer red because it maximizes patient com fort and ease of catheter placement and care. Deep pelvic lesions occasionally are inaccessible by the transabdominal or transgluteal approach because of intervening viscera, such as bowel, bladder, and uterus, or vascular and osseous structures [4]. In these situations, the endorectal approach and, in women, the transvaginal route are useful alternatives. The endorectal method is a relatively nonsterile technique with limited range of motion for the radiologist. This route is useful for gaining access to pelvic fluid collections posterior to or abutting the rectum.
Sonographically guided transvaginal drainage of pelvic fluid collections was described in the early 1990s [4, 5]. This approach is not widely used, however, owing to radiologists' lack of familiarity with the procedure and the paucity of data to guide case selection and prediction of long-term clinical outcome. We review our 13-year experience with sonographically guided transvaginal procedures, including the technique, whether aspiration or catheter drainage was used, the complication rate, and whether long-term success was achieved.
|
|
|---|
Medical Record Review
A search of the interventional radiology database at our institution for
records of all women who underwent sonographically guided transvaginal
procedures from 1994 to 2006 identified 85 transvaginal procedures performed
on 67 patients. One radiologist retrospectively reviewed and abstracted data
from all institutional medical records, including outpatient, emergency
department, and hospital admission and discharge notes; relevant diagnostic
and procedure-related imaging reports; and surgical, pathologic,
microbiologic, and other laboratory reports. The following data were
abstracted: patient demographic character istics; underlying cause, size, and
location of cyst or fluid collection; type of transvaginal inter vention
(aspiration alone or catheter placement); needle or catheter size; volume of
fluid aspirated; duration of catheter drainage; presence or absence of resi
dual fluid; and procedure complications. Follow-up clinical data documenting
recurrent fluid collection, symptoms, and subsequent imaging-guided procedures
or surgery were recorded.
Sonographically Guided Transvaginal Procedure
The sonographically guided transvaginal drainage procedures were performed
as pre viously described [10].
A team consisting of one of 19 attending staff interventional radiologists (a
pool that included five of the authors) and an interventional radiology fellow
performed the procedures. All procedures were performed with conscious
sedation induced by IV administration of 1–4 mg of midazolam
hydrochloride and 20–100 µg of fentanyl citrate. Immediately before
the procedure, 1 g of ampicillin, 80 mg of gentamicin, and 600 mg of
clindamycin were administered IV. Patients not undergoing long-term IV
antibiotic therapy were treated with 150 mg clindamycin orally every 8 hours
for 5 days after the procedure.
The patient was asked to drain her bladder immediately before the procedure, or a Foley catheter was placed. The patient was placed in the lithotomy position, and the perineum and vaginal vault were cleaned with 10% povidone–iodine (Betadine, Purdue Frederick). A sheathed transvaginal ultrasound probe with a guide was placed in the vaginal fornix closest to the lesion, and the projected drainage path was scrutinized for intervening structures, such as intestine, bladder, and blood vessels. Once the probe was well positioned, the needle guide was aligned in the center of the lesion, and a 16- to 20-gauge needle or an 8- to 12-French trocar locking pigtail catheter (Dawson-Mueller Drainage Catheter, Cook) was advanced into the fluid collection under continuous sonographic visualization. No incision was made in the vaginal fornix before needle or catheter placement. In patients who underwent aspiration alone, with either needle or catheter, the fluid was completely drained to minimize the risk of superinfection of the residual contents. Specimens of all fluid collections were obtained for microbiologic examination. Specimens of ovarian cysts and of fluid collections after resection of malignant tumors were obtained for cytologic examination.
Catheter Care
The catheter was attached to a gravity drainage system and secured to the
anterior aspect of the thigh with a rubber leg band. The catheter was flushed
every 8 hours with 10 mL of sterile saline solution and was removed once
output decreased to less than 10 mL/24 hours and symptoms diminished. Imaging
with CT or sonography usually was performed to document complete drainage
before catheter removal.
Criteria for Patient Selection
The decision to intervene was initiated by a referring clinician on the
basis of the patient's clinical presentation and after consultation with the
interventional radiologist. Postoperative fluid collections were drained if
symptomatic, that is, pain or signs of infection were present, and if the
collection seen at imaging was the likely cause of the symptoms. Tuboovarian
abscesses caused by pelvic inflammatory disease were drained if the patient
did not respond to medical treatment alone. Tuboovarian abscesses caused by
bowel lesions were drained if the patient had symptoms and signs of infection,
such as fever and an elevated WBC. Definitive surgery, such as sigmoid
colectomy or appendectomy, was performed after the inflammatory process sub
sided. Aspiration of ovarian cysts was considered if the clinical team
considered the cyst the likely cause of pelvic pain. The imaging appearance of
the ovarian cyst also was considered before aspiration. Except in a few
unusual circumstances, only simple benign-appearing ovarian cysts were
considered for aspiration.
Type of Transvaginal Procedure: Aspiration or Catheter Drainage
The choice of aspiration alone or catheter drainage was made by the
attending radiologist performing the procedure in consultation with the
referring clinical service. All fluid was initially aspirated with a needle. A
catheter was left in place if the aspirated material was purulent, if residual
fluid was present after an attempt at complete aspiration was unsuccessful, or
if bowel communication was suspected.
Data Analysis and Statistics
Technical success was defined as complete drainage of the fluid. Clinical
success was defined as long-term avoidance of surgery. Complications were
classified as major or minor according to the Society of Interventional
Radiology criteria [11]. Tests
and summary measures of association were performed with the chi-square test
(www.graphpad.com/quickcalcs/chisquared1.cfm).
A bayes ian calculator
(www.causascientia.org/math_stat/ProportionCI.html)
was used to calculate the 95% CI of proportions.
|
|
|---|
|
Type of Transvaginal Procedure: Aspiration Alone or Catheter Drainage
The transvaginal route was chosen only if the fluid collection was
inaccessible with the percutaneous method, that is, the transabdominal or
transgluteal approach. Table 2
categorizes the procedures by underlying cause and type of procedure, that is,
aspiration or catheter placement. For complete drainage, aspiration alone
sufficed for all 23 symptomatic ovarian cysts (Fig.
1A,
1B); catheter placement was
needed for 91% (20 of 22) of tuboovarian abscesses persis tent after medical
therapy (Fig. 2A,
2B). Post operative fluid
collections were managed with aspira tion for 45% (14 of 31) of patients and
with catheter drainage for 55% (17 of 31) of patients. The mean duration of
catheter drainage was 4.5 days (range, 2–12 days). Catheter placement
was successful in every case in which it was attempted. In the case of one
tuboovarian abscess, although initial aspira tion yielded pus, a catheter was
not left in place because intervening vessels pre cluded a safe trajectory for
catheter placement.
|
|
|
|
|
Complications
According to the Society of Interventional Radiology criteria, no
complications occurred in patients who underwent aspiration alone. Among
patients who underwent catheter placement, there were no major complications
but four minor complications. In two cases, the catheter transgressed the
urinary bladder and was discovered on days 1 and 7 after the procedure. The
first patient presented with urinary leak through the transvaginal catheter on
postprocedure day 1. Bladder transgression was confirmed with CT of the
abdomen and pelvis and catheter injection (Fig.
3A,
3B,
3C,
3D). The patient was treated
conservatively with re moval of the pigtail catheter and placement of a Foley
catheter for 10 days. The second patient had a transvaginal catheter in place
because of a tuboovarian abscess secondary to sigmoid diverticulitis. This
patient had no symptoms related to bladder transgression, which was an
incidental finding on postprocedure day 7 at cystoscopy performed for stent
placement. The pigtail catheter was removed, and the patient was treated
conservatively with placement of a Foley catheter for 21 days. In one case,
infection introduced into a postoperative fluid collection via the
transvaginal catheter necessitated additional antibiotic therapy. The fluid
was initially sterile and grew Escherichia coli on day 7. One patient
had severe catheter-related pain presumably due to irritation at the catheter
insertion site that was relieved with catheter removal.
|
|
|
|
Long-Term Clinical Success
Table 3 shows clinical
success in avoidance of surgery. Overall, surgery was avoided by 75% (50 of
67) of patients, including all patients with postoperative fluid collections,
71% (12 of 17) of patients with tuboovarian abscesses unresponsive to medical
therapy, and 41% (seven of 17) of patients with symptomatic ovarian cysts.
|
Twenty-five percent (17 of 67) of patients needed surgery, including five patients with tuboovarian abscesses, 10 with symptomatic ovarian cysts, one with hydrosalpinx, and one with pyometra. Four patients with tubo ovarian abscess were unsuccessfully treated and had recurrence of the fluid collection after catheter removal, which necessitated surgery for sigmoid diverticulitis (n = 3) and pelvic inflammatory disease (n = 1). One patient with a tuboovarian abscess secondary to sigmoid diverticulitis was successfully treated but needed sigmoid colectomy for definitive management. One case of hydro salpinx and one of pyometra necessitated surgery. Ten patients with ovarian cysts reported symptom relief immediately after aspiration but needed surgery for cyst and symptom recurrence.
Two patients with serous tumors of borderline malignant tumors were referred by an experienced gynecologist specializing in gynecologic oncology with full understanding that the tumors might not be benign. The lesion in a 56-year-old patient with multiple myeloma and breast cancer was discovered at staging CT. We aspirated this lesion both for diagnosis and to stabilize the patient's condition until she became fit for laparoscopic resection. The second patient was 23 years old at presentation and had a history of left oophorectomy and right cystectomy for serous borderline tumor. Beginning in 1992, she underwent aspiration of recurrent cysts on four occasions in a successful effort to preserve fertility until elective surgical resection in 2006 (Fig. 4). Neither patient with borderline tumor had evidence of tumor recurrence after 5 years and 1 year of follow-up.
|
Requirement for Additional Imaging-Guided Procedures
Table 4 shows the
imaging-guided procedures performed after the initial transvaginal drainage
procedure. Overall, 10% (seven of 67) of the patients needed additional
imaging-guided procedures. Three patients with postoperative fluid collections
needed a second procedure because the catheter was dislodged prematurely
(n = 2) or because of the presence of residual undrained fluid
(n = 1). All of these patients avoided surgery. Three patients with
symptomatic ovarian cysts underwent repeated transvaginal aspiration because
of cyst recurrence but ultimately needed surgical resection. In two of the
three patients, cysts recurred 3 and 5 months after the procedure. The third
patient was the 23-year-old patient with borderline malignancy discussed
earlier, and she needed four transvaginal aspiration procedures. The patient
with pyometra underwent repeated transvaginal catheter drainage 3 months after
the initial procedure because of reaccumulation of fluid and eventually
underwent hysterectomy.
|
|
|
|---|
Postoperative fluid collections were amenable to transvaginal drainage, and all patients avoided additional surgery. Neither aspiration nor catheter placement was used preferentially. However, additional drainage procedures were needed by a small proportion of these patients (12%, three of 25) because of premature catheter displacement or presence of residual undrained fluid. Our high success rate with transvaginal drainage of postoperative pelvic fluid collections is similar to that reported for percutaneous drainage under sonographic or CT guidance [16–18].
Uncomplicated tuboovarian abscesses are typically managed with broad-spectrum IV anti biotics. The rate of success of medical treatment alone has been reported to range from 34% to 87.5% [14]. When symptoms persist or if rupture is suspected, surgical intervention, either laparoscopy or laparotomy, is required. Percutaneous or transvaginal drainage has proved to be a useful alternative to surgery if an abscess persists despite medical therapy [14, 15, 19–21]. In a large series of 302 patients with tuboovarian abscess who were treated at presentation with a combination of IV antibiotics and transvaginal aspiration, Gjelland et al. [14] reported an overall success rate of 93.4%, with 34.8% of patients needing repeated aspiration procedures. In contrast, in our study, all patients with a tuboovarian abscess had already undergone a course of IV antibiotic therapy. In this setting, most of the fluid collections in our series (91%, 20 of 22) necessitated catheter placement for complete drainage; 71% patients (12 of 17) avoided surgery. No additional imaging-guided procedures were needed by any of the patients treated successfully. Thus, even in patients with tuboovarian abscesses unresponsive to medical management, transvaginal catheter drainage remains a relatively effective therapeutic option for avoiding surgery.
Results of some studies [22–26] support the use of sonographically guided therapeutic aspiration of symptomatic ovarian cysts as a viable alterative to surgical excision. Those authors emphasize the need for careful patient selection and recommend that the procedure be attempted only on patients with cysts thought to be benign after thorough clinical and imaging evaluation. Some authors [22, 27–31] argue against therapeutic aspiration of ovarian cysts, citing high recurrence rates and concern about peritoneal spillage of malignant cells should an occult malignant tumor be drained. The reported recurrence rates after sonographically guided aspiration of symptomatic ovarian cysts range from 25% to 75% [22–26, 32]. In our series, aspiration alone completely drained all ovarian cysts and led to symptomatic relief for all patients. However, more than one half of these patients (59%, 10 of 17) ultimately needed surgery because of recurrence. Noting similarly high rates of cyst recurrence, previous investigators [33, 34] have proposed the use of alcohol as a sclerosing agent. Because cyst recurrence can indicate that a lesion is not benign, as in the cases of two lesions in our series, surgical resection of a recurrent cyst rather than repetition of drainage with sclerosis is indicated.
Previous results [4, 5, 12–15, 35, 36] on transvaginal drainage show it to be a relatively safe procedure. In our series, no complications occurred after aspiration alone. Catheter drainage, however, was associated with a 10% complication rate (four of 40 patients). All complications were classified as minor according to the Society of Interventional Radiology criteria. In general, the potential complications of trans vaginal drainage are similar to those of the percutaneous approach, including bleed ing and bowel or bladder injury. Two cases of bladder injury were encountered in our series. One case of bladder transgression occurred during drainage of a 6-cm-diameter cul-de-sac collection, and the second during drainage of a 3-cm right adnexal collection. Both patients had tuboovarian abscesses. Super infection and fistula formation are complications specifically related to trans vaginal drainage. One case of the former occurred in our series [4]. Premature dislodgment of the catheter is a management issue likely more common in transvaginal drainage because the catheter cannot be secured with sutures. Five percent (two of 40) of catheter drainage patients in our study needed a second imaging-guided drainage procedure because the catheter was dis lodged prematurely. Therefore, the transvaginal route is less desirable if long-term drainage is anticipated.
Limitations of this study were the retrospective nature and the relatively small population in comparison with previous series of percutaneous drainage procedures. Because at our institution surgery is the therapeutic option of choice for tuboovarian abscesses unresponsive to medical therapy and for any symptomatic ovarian cysts, our cohort of patients referred for imaging-guided drainage favored those who declined surgery or were considered poor candidates for surgery. This selection bias would likely have increased the incidence of comorbid conditions in our study population, for which we have not accounted. The relatively small sample size in each subcategory restricted our ability to draw conclusions with reasonable statistical certainty to only the three most common causes. We did not contact the referring clinicians to determine whether any of their patients underwent follow-up with additional procedures or surgery at an institution other than ours. Finally, our cases were acquired over a period spanning several generations of sonography and other imaging techniques and included a large pool of interventional radiologists with a range of procedural experience. However, throughout the study, common guidelines were followed in case selection, choice of technique, procedure performance, and postprocedure follow-up.
Sonographically guided transvaginal aspiration or catheter drainage of pelvic fluid collections is a useful alternative when the percutaneous approach is not feasible. Postoperative fluid collections can be managed successfully with this approach. Transvaginal drainage appears to be a reasonable option for avoiding surgery on tuboovarian ab scesses that are unresponsive to medical management. Cath eter placement usually is necessary to avoid repeated drainage procedures. In our series, catheter drainage was associated with minor complications in 10% of patients. Ovarian cysts were reliably drained, and symptomatic relief was achieved with aspiration alone. However, most cysts recur, and those that do should be surgically resected to exclude the possibility that they are lowgrade or frankly malignant neoplasms.
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |